Pros and Cons of Owning Florida Vacation Rental Property vs. Annual Rental Property in Sarasota

Vacation homes on a Florida beach.

Table of Contents

About the City of Sarasota

Sarasota, located on the southwestern coast of Florida, is a captivating city known for its stunning beaches, vibrant arts scene, and rich cultural heritage. It attracts vacationers from near and far, offering a diverse range of attractions and activities. One of the main draws is its pristine white-sand beaches, including Siesta Key Beach, consistently ranked among the top beaches in the United States. 

Visitors flock to Sarasota to bask in the warm sun, swim in the turquoise waters of the Gulf of Mexico, and indulge in a variety of water sports such as kayaking, paddleboarding, and fishing.

Beyond its beautiful beaches, Sarasota boasts a thriving arts and culture scene. The city is home to numerous art galleries, theaters, and performing arts venues, including the renowned Ringling Museum of Art, which houses an impressive collection of European masterpieces. 

Additionally, Sarasota hosts the annual Sarasota Opera Festival and the Sarasota Film Festival, attracting culture enthusiasts from around the world. Outdoor enthusiasts can explore the scenic beauty of the Myakka River State Park, where activities like hiking, wildlife spotting, and airboat rides await.

The Pros and Cons of Vacation Rental Property in Sarasota, FL

Owning a rental property in Sarasota, Florida, presents a unique opportunity to capitalize on the city’s vibrant tourism industry and steady local rental market. One critical decision you need to make as a property owner is whether to offer your property as an annual rental or a short-term rental. 

In this blog post, we will explore key pros and cons to consider when making this decision, helping you determine which rental strategy aligns with your goals and maximizes the potential of your Sarasota property.

The Pros

Favorable Climate: Sarasota enjoys a warm climate throughout the year, making it an appealing destination for travelers seeking to escape colder regions. The pleasant weather contributes to an extended vacation season, increasing your rental property’s occupancy rates.

Diverse Attractions: Florida offers a diverse range of attractions, including beautiful beaches, amusement parks (such as Walt Disney World and Universal Studios), natural parks, golf courses, and vibrant cities like Miami and Orlando. This variety appeals to a wide range of tourists, ensuring a constant influx of potential renters.

Rental Income Potential: Due to the high demand and popularity of Florida as a vacation destination, rental rates can be quite lucrative. You have the potential to generate significant rental income from your property, especially during peak tourist seasons.

Tax Benefits: Florida has no state income tax, which can be advantageous for property owners. Additionally, there may be tax deductions available for expenses related to maintaining and managing your vacation rental property.

Tourism Infrastructure: Florida has a well-developed tourism infrastructure with efficient transportation networks, including airports and major highways. This infrastructure makes it easier for travelers to reach your property, enhancing its accessibility and appeal.

Vacation Home for Personal Use: Owning a vacation rental property in Florida allows you to enjoy your property during your own vacations. You can take advantage of the desirable location and amenities for your personal enjoyment while generating rental income during the rest of the year.

Evaluate Local Market Demand – To make an informed decision, begin by assessing the demand for both annual and short-term rentals in Sarasota. Research the local market trends, including vacancy rates, rental prices, and the availability of comparable properties. Determine whether the area experiences a higher demand for long-term residents seeking stability or short-term tourists looking for vacation rentals. Understanding the market dynamics will provide valuable insights into the rental strategy that is more likely to generate consistent income and minimize vacancies.

Consider Rental Regulations and Homeowner Association (HOA) Rules – Review the local rental regulations and HOA guidelines governing rental properties in Sarasota. Some areas may have specific rules and restrictions regarding short-term rentals, such as limitations on rental durations or required permits. Ensure you are compliant with all legal requirements to avoid potential fines or legal complications. Additionally, consult the HOA rules, as some communities may have restrictions or guidelines regarding rental terms. Understanding these regulations will help you determine the feasibility and practicality of offering short-term rentals.

Analyze Financial Considerations – Evaluate the financial aspects associated with each rental strategy. Consider the potential rental income for both annual and short-term rentals in Sarasota. Compare the expected rental rates, occupancy rates, and associated expenses, such as property management fees, utility costs, and maintenance expenses. Determine which strategy offers a higher potential return on investment. Additionally, factor in seasonality for short-term rentals, as the rental rates and occupancy levels may fluctuate depending on peak and off-peak seasons.

Assess Property Management Options – Consider the management requirements and associated costs for each rental strategy. Short-term rentals typically involve more hands-on management, including guest communications, cleaning between stays, and frequent property inspections. If you opt for short-term rentals, consider whether you have the time, resources, and expertise to handle these responsibilities effectively. Alternatively, hiring a professional property management company can alleviate the burden and ensure the smooth operation of your rental property.

On the other hand, annual rentals generally require less intensive management, as the tenants typically stay for longer durations. However, it is still crucial to evaluate whether you want to handle tenant screenings, lease agreements, rent collection, and property maintenance yourself or outsource these tasks to a property management company.

The Cons

Intense Competition: Florida’s popularity as a vacation destination also means that there is intense competition among vacation rental property owners. You’ll need to differentiate your property and invest in marketing efforts to stand out from the competition.

Seasonal Fluctuations: Florida experiences distinct peak and off-peak seasons, with high demand during the winter months and lower demand during the summer. Including Sarasota. This means that you may face challenges in maintaining consistent occupancy rates and rental income throughout the year.

Property Management Challenges: Managing a vacation rental property can be time-consuming and demanding. You’ll need to handle guest inquiries, bookings, check-ins, cleanings, maintenance, and other property management tasks. If you’re not local to the area, it can be even more challenging to oversee these responsibilities effectively.

Property Damage and Wear: Vacation rentals can experience more wear and tear compared to long-term rentals or personal homes. Guests may not treat the property as carefully, resulting in increased maintenance and repair costs.

Seasonal Expenses: In addition to potential fluctuations in rental income, seasonal expenses can also impact your profitability. These may include higher utility bills during peak seasons, increased marketing expenses, and higher property management fees if you use a professional management company.

Changing Regulations: Vacation rental regulations and ordinances can vary across different cities and counties in Florida. It’s crucial to stay informed about any changes in local regulations that may affect your ability to rent out your property or impact your operating procedures.

Hurricanes and Natural Disasters: Florida is prone to hurricanes and other natural disasters, which can pose a risk to your vacation rental property. Insurance costs may be higher, and you’ll need to consider measures to protect your property during severe weather events.

Additional Costs and Fees: Owning a vacation rental property comes with additional costs beyond the purchase price. These may include property taxes, insurance, homeowner association fees (if applicable), licensing fees, permits, and ongoing maintenance expenses.

Guest Turnover and Management: Managing a constant turnover of guests can be challenging. Coordinating check-ins, check-outs, cleaning schedules, and addressing guest issues or complaints can be time-consuming and require prompt attention.

Economic Factors: Sarasota’s tourism industry can be influenced by economic factors, such as recessions or global events that affect travel patterns. During economic downturns, there may be a decline in tourism, impacting your rental income and occupancy rates.

It’s important to weigh these cons against the pros and conduct a thorough analysis of the local vacation rental market in Florida before making a decision. Proper planning, effective marketing, and efficient property management can help mitigate some of these challenges and increase your chances of success.


Determining whether to make your Sarasota rental property an annual or short-term rental is a crucial decision that should align with your goals and financial considerations. Carefully evaluate the local market demand, rental regulations, financial aspects, and management requirements. Take into account factors such as income potential, property maintenance, legal compliance, and personal preferences. By conducting thorough research and analysis, you can make an informed choice that optimizes the success and profitability of your Sarasota rental property.

Thank you for taking the time to read our blog. Gulf Income Properties is a full service Sarasota County and Manatee County property management company. For more information about our services, visit our website at

Connect with a Property Manager!

Get a team of Local Experts behind your Investment Property.

Share this blog with your friends.


Follow Us on Social Media!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top